# Reticulum Developer Summit 2026/27

_General · started by lava on Wed, Nov 18, 2026 4:04 PM_

---

## Original post

**lava** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 4:04 PM

## Open invitation to join the Reticulum Developer Summit 2026/27
*Utrecht, November 2026*

This is Lava, working with Reticulum communities in Utrecht in the Netherlands and Bremen in Germany. Together with a group of grassroots Reticulum organizers and developers, we plan to organize a Reticulum Developer Summit soon, and that is why I am writing to you. The focus of the summit is to address some of the important questions and challenges Reticulum developers and users currently face. We see the need to find a path forward together in terms of interoperability, community-building and deployment. This perception is the result of many conversation we had with different people and in different places where Reticulum community networks are actively being built.

We would like to facilitate the summit at one of the upcoming hacker conventions or online, depending on your plans. This first summit could evolve into a recurring meeting, if the need arises. To coordinate and prepare the summit, we prepared [**this survey form**](https://files.criticalinfralab.net/apps/forms/embed/wwbACJrmSfJ5f4t8GQCAN8M9).

Fill it out to help us organize the summit in a way that is meaningful to Reticulum developers, as well as to community stakeholders! It should not take more than 10 minutes to do this. Data is stored on servers operated by Greenhost in the Netherlands on behalf of the critical infrastructure lab at Utrecht University and the University of Amsterdam. There is currently no specific funding for this research, we are doing it in our research time and as volunteers for the benefit of Reticulum communities, although we might look for funding depending on the results. If you know someone that should be part of this conversation, feel free to send me their contact info, or forward this message!

Thank you,
Lava,
intern with the critical infrastructure lab

LXMF address: a210bb15b4fb5948dba55e7338e8b372

Email address: survey@criticalinfralab.net

ps: the research is done in collaboration with Maxigas (Dr. Peter Dunajcsik), community organiser and Assistant Professor of Computational Methods at Utrecht University, Department of Media and Culture, as well as co-Principal Investigator of the critical infrastructure lab — who is ultimately responsible for the research.

---

## Reply 1

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 4:43 PM

Relevant context:

- [The Movement Of A Dozen](https://reticulum.network/manual/brandolinis.html#the-movement-of-a-dozen)
- [A History Of What Works](https://reticulum.network/manual/brandolinis.html#a-history-of-what-works)

As far as I recall, "Maxigas" has been quite involved in attempting to market the "Reticulum needs GOVERNANCE" narrative, as well as LLM-generated clones of RNS.

---

## Reply 2

**aetherlab** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 5:11 PM

Stakeholders? This sounds like Claus Schwab's "inclusive capitalism", the one that envisioned us all devoid of any ownership over anything, including our souls. What is this, some kind of an attempt to officialize an overtake? Who are "you"? Who are the "grassroots Reticulum organizers and developers"? Maxigas, the emperor-governor??? What the hell is a co-principal investigator?! This is like calling Oriflame a Honorary Beauty Academy, like this will magically turn it into something different than a pyramid...

https://reticulum.network/manual/brandolinis.html#the-method-of-madness
As Mark put it - Weaponizaed Concern and The legitimacy circuit
P.S. And if this isn't a classic grant-eater... The utter bullshit of this description reminds me of the fart of politics for the last 50 years - absolute Tavistock talk!!! 
"Maxigas is Assistant Professor of Computational Methods for Media and Culture Studies at Utrecht University and co-Principal Investigator with the critical infrastructure lab.  His co-authored monograph with Johan Söderberg, Resistance to the Current: The Dialectics of Hacking, is a theoretical driven collection of case studies on the politics of informational capitalism, accounting for the long-term trajectory of hacker cultures.  His research interest is how infrastructural ideologies translate to digital materialities, which he currently explores through studying standards and protocols related to programmable infrastructures such as 5G networks."

P.P.S OH THIS ONE I BEAUTIFUL TOO! The pillars of understanding!!!
The people that turned science from careful observation, rigorous skepticism, hypothesis testing, and experimental validation into a freaking item for public debate, opinion and subjectivization! From an empirically derived truth into adolescent ranting subjectivity...
"Johan Söderberg is associate professor (docent) in Theory of Science. He gives classes in classic and modern theory of science. In his research, Söderberg studies conflicting truth and value claims in the public debate and in communities outside of scientific institutions."

---

## Reply 3

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 5:43 PM

> grant-eater

Thanks @aetherlab, that was exactly the word missing from my vocabulary here :)

---

## Reply 4

**flok** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 6:29 PM

I don't necessarily see the issue in trying to bring reticulum communities together? Is it that it's people on universities organising this? I've been organising with lava and maxigas and two other folks for the past two years running workshops - mostly in the netherlands, but we also did a couple abroad - teaching people how to get onboarded to reticulum and pushing for more mesh network adoption and I think to call us grant-eaters is a bit misguided considering we've been putting our own time and money into this all that time. Now we have regular events in utrecht, rotterdam and amsterdam where people meet and play with it and maintain the public access points to the network.  it wouldn't hurt you aetherlab to have a little bit of humbleness and curiosity and ask questions before you write this kind of shit, Check some other bios of university professors this is what classic academia gobbly-gook language looks like. What is there to overtake? You think this is some multi-million business? Your soul? idk chief i think ur overreacting a lil bit

---

## Reply 5

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 6:47 PM

> I don't necessarily see the issue in trying to bring reticulum communities together?

Who said anything about that? That is not what this is.

What I specifically try to make people aware of here, is that this is primarily arranged by one of the (quite few) people that are very keen to undermine the work of the Reticulum community, so they can gain something themself from the perceived vacuum.

If I am entirely incorrect on that point, I will gladly take the information that points towards this not being the case.

For example, let me know whether those workshops were actually about teaching people to use Reticulum, the RNS stack, and all of the other software and hardware we have created here?

Or about organizing around getting "alternative" implementations built in a hurry (often by LLM-cloning RNS)? Or "discussing governance" and "license issues"?

Again, I *am* open to hearing being wrong here, but from what I have seen of your group - and I could have just been *extremely* statistically unfortunate, but I have been following what you are doing a bit - the primary focus for Maxigas and the "critical infrastructure lab" has, let's just say, **not** been a positive one of support for the Reticulum developers and community. At all.

---

## Reply 6

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 6:50 PM

Also, I know this was a reply to @aetherlab:

> you think this is some multi-million business

But, FYI, academia, "the grantiverse" and universities (especially) *is* a multi-million bussiness, in case you somehow missed the news.

Maybe you think everything is good and "for the people" because it has a university logo stamped on it. That is not, necessarily, the case.

---

## Reply 7

**flok** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:00 PM

Yeah usually on a workshop we do an introduction into what reticulum is, a very simple description of what a mesh network does. Then we split into two-three groups, depending on how many facilitators and participants we have. One learns how to make micron pages, one goes to mess with physical infrastructure - usually lora nodes - and one is a more beginner/non-techie group which gets set up with an app on their phone. typically we use columba for it's ease of onboarding.

We discuss the politics of mesh networks, what kind of access we have to the radio spectrum as civil society, how can this be useful for our needs. I'm pretty surprised at the picture that you got of what's happening, because I don't recall ever trying to get an alternative implementation built, doing a takeover or shilling AI implementations in our workshops. I personally like the reticulum license and don't see it as an issue. I'm not gonna speak for maxigas here, i think it's best if you two talk and maybe that will clear some stuff up.

---

## Reply 8

**tyise** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:05 PM

I don't think you actually visited any of the workshops, otherwise it would have been very clear to you how much time, energy and personal resources Maxigas and others have invested in educating people on the use of Reticulum and the RNS Stack. Outside of universities, working with marginalised groups.
It is truly painful to read these responses, knowing how much this group has been supporting Reticulum, defending it, maintaining the network, etc. And all that time trying to stay true to its politics, which are woven into the set up of the workshops as well.

---

## Reply 9

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:07 PM

@flok, so what you describe there sounds perfectly awesome, and incredibly helpful.

It does not at all track with my impression of what Maxigas' project has been. But I think it's very unconstructive to discuss someone who is not actually present, and I have already stated my impressions on the subject.

If he wishes to change that impression, he is incredibly welcome to actually come here himself and state his opinions on these matters personally.

Otherwise we are just discussing in thin air, which is pointless.

---

## Reply 10

**decentral1se** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:24 PM

I fully support this initiative, thanks lava and others! I fully do not support the toxic online behaviour on display in this thread, and elsewhere on this forum, sadly. I don't understand how you can be marked as a "moderator" on this forum and then continue to spew vitriol and unfounded claims about others.

---

## Reply 11

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:25 PM

> I don't think you actually visited any of the workshops

No, I can't just race to a workshop in Amsterdam. Sry, no money for that. I have been following some of the online stuff that was arranged, though. And back then, there was very much a focus on replacing RNS as the reference stack, and me as the maintainer with something else.

> It is truly painful to read these responses

If that is indeed the truth, I can understand that.

I'll invite you to see things from my perspective as well, in terms of pain felt. I don't think you have much idea about the actual, real pain, both phsyical and mental, that I am continously going through, while providing all of this.

And then having it shat on left and right, while still continuing to maintain and work dilligently for 12-14 hours a day, putting out release after release, while people keep posting and holding conference talks on the same shit about me not maintaining the project, et cetera, et cetera. How do you think *that* feels?

At some point, tolerance drops to zero, and once that has occurred, and you see someone peddle the same BS just a few times (which I did see with Maxigas), you just file it mentally as something not to waste anymore time on.

---

## Reply 12

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:29 PM

> I fully do not support the toxic online behaviour

What exactly is it that is toxic here?

> continue to spew vitriol

Again, what parts of my writing here do you consider vitriol, exactly?

---

## Reply 13

**bettertaste** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:47 PM

**Mark** wrote:
> What I specifically try to make people aware of here, is that this is primarily arranged by one of the (quite few) people that are very keen to undermine the work of the Reticulum community, so they can gain something themself from the perceived vacuum.
> 
> If I am entirely incorrect on that point, I will gladly take the information that points towards this not being the case.

Jumping in here with information (personal experience) as I have attended quite some of these workshops/gatherings and you are dead wrong and it sounds like a statistical problem - better to chat with the people and get to know them than to assume the worst from what sounds like rumors and second hand accounts you have received. 

On the academic point you seem to be confusing the forest for the individual trees... A McDonalds employee is not a multi-billionaire because McDonalds is a multi-billion dollar company. Most academics I know (even the lecturers and profs) are not rolling in money (they are mostly broke-ass tbh) and do many many unpaid hours simply to say afloat and the ones that have a social conscience also do a lot of community work to share their knowledge, try to get their institution to provide space/resources etc. for social projects etc. 

I am not saying that academia as a whole gets a free pass, the transformation of universities into businesses forces academics to sell themselves and their ideas, there are arrogant people (same as everywhere else in life) etc. etc. - but again, many academics are simply trying to survive and do something that they find somewhat interesting / valuable - same as many non-academic people.

Anyways, I am hoping I can find the time to attend this summit and I would encourage you to join if you can (what resources would it take? I am sure people would be excited to try to make it possible if it was a train ticket or something). If it is the same kinds of people from the workshops it will be a lot of fun and you would find yourself in good company and possibly more anti-establishment than yourself ;)

---

## Reply 14

**aetherlab** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:50 PM

Here we go again...
https://reticulum.network/manual/brandolinis.html#intent-consequence
https://reticulum.network/manual/brandolinis.html#recognition-response
Being one of the driving elements behind a push to centralize and GOVERN the network is an unfounded claim? It reminds me of the other governor, Lew Palm. This is the true toxicity, not me being blunt and straightforward about it. And, of course, the cardboard protesters...
You are marked as a moderator in this forum for being true to zen and not take bullshit lightly. Also for actually creating something useful and thought trough, operating a network, WRITING code with your own hands, designing well engineered devices and sharing them, building a REAL PHYSICAL network infrastructure and operating it, remaining true to the source and showing due respect and gratitude where it is due. Stuff like that.

---

## Reply 15

**aetherlab** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:53 PM

**Mark** wrote:
> 
> At some point, tolerance drops to zero, and once that has occurred, and you see someone peddle the same BS just a few times (which I did see with Maxigas), you just file it mentally as something not to waste anymore time on.

I second that! If no one peddles bullshit we turn into e very cheerful and supportive crowd! You will be amazed how much more you can learn HERE than on those workshops, you will be blown away...
The collective experience here is mind-boggling and this goes AGAINST the fact how FEW actually have any true experience at all!
But the moment we smell the foul stench of this type of BS, the shovel flips and they are met with the fat end of the handle.
Now time, strength, nerves to waste anymore on such things. There is a network to build and principles to uphold.

---

## Reply 16

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 7:54 PM

I was about to screenshot the part of the survey which has "Governance" as a choice for things to discuss at this Reticulum Developer Summit, but it seems that option has been removed between my first post and now.

> On the academic point you seem to be confusing the forest for the individual trees...

No, that is exactly the opposite of what I am doing. I targeted only *one* person with that remark - the guy who is actually, very clearly making his living on grants.

I said nothing about any other individuals or people running workshops and helping out and doing great work.

You put that into my mouth with silly comments like that, @bettertaste.

---

## Reply 17

**aetherlab** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:00 PM

Of course it was. Most probably Mr. Maximum Gas is here under some anon moniker.

---

## Reply 18

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:05 PM

Instead, we have the ever-relevant topics such as

![survey_options.png](/storage/forum/QDLlve9HO9aQVdzNZ8raAqlExnjO87QswreVD6iW.png)

- *Decentralization of development!* Hint hint, nudge nudge.

As if the development was not already decentralized. What does that actually *mean* here? What is possibly being hinted at?

- *The lack of a formal specification as a hindrance to interoperability*

As if that has been a problem for anyone actually working on Reticulum or alternative implementations so far. Maybe you haven't heard, but the few good alternative implementations that actually exist and contribute to the entire ecosystem have no problems in these regards.

Or what, should we have a few more of those sloppy LLM-generated "FoRMaL sPEcS"? Which are - as a side note - *also* unlicensed, copyright-violating derivatives of RNS.

The reference implementation **is** the specification.

- *A Reticulum Foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers*

**Lol, *what* the fuck now**? And some of you are claiming this is not at all about money?

And, err... You did not *for one second* think to present me with any of these ideas first?

Or at least, even so much as *mention* this "Reticulum Developer Summit" in a mail or LXM to me or something?

And you expect me *not* to raise an eyebrow over this, when it is suddenly dumped as a link on this forum, from someone who we've never seen posting here before?

This all smells so funny, that it's not even funny.

---

## Reply 19

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:13 PM

If this is really *all*, completely and honestly in good intentions, you'll have to realize that how this has all been presented was incredibly, catastrophically without situational awareness and understanding about what is going on in the *actual* Reticulum developer community - as in:

**Those people who actually work on Reticulum and related software practically every day, and make this network and entire system work and survive despite massive challenges**

I would love to know who the Reticulum Developers you are targeting with these kinds of "important topics for discussion" are? Can you link to their projects or public profiles, please?

Because my understanding, from **actually talking with and supporting Reticulum developers every day**, is that it's **completely different things they are concerned with and spending their time and efforts on**.

---

## Reply 20

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:20 PM

Also, for the record, both @lava and @bettertaste here are first time poster - they just registered on this forum today, and we haven't seen them before here.

---

## Reply 21

**flok** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:24 PM

@Mark feel free to shoot me a dm at 3139c1fa6446992c97862f2be639bdb9 i'd be more than happy to chat with you about all this and go in a bit more detail that i don't necessarily want to be publicly available

---

## Reply 22

**oatmilk!** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:25 PM

going to come in here and give a middle of the road, and also explain how this looks to me as someone who wasn't here for a 4-7 month period.

**tyise** wrote:
> [...]

as someone who spends far too much time on the culturally enforced moral ocd hellhole that is Tumblr, fuck off with the "oh you're being so mean to me and the minorities who I'm speaking for" 

as for the OP, this is like trying to have a linux conference, but making it so that Linus Torvalds can't make it. if this is as academic as you say, have a telepresence setup, and host it on zoom or possibly even over the fucking ret` as you can do at least voice calls on that, and let mark attend that way so he can see the legitimacy. 

**flok** wrote
>  I don't recall ever trying to get an alternative implementation built, doing a takeover or shilling AI implementations in our workshops.

> typically we use columba for it's ease of onboarding. 


Columbia is literally one of the ai implementations that has had a history of degrading the network due to the dev making some truly idiotic decisions around transport nodes and the dev not understanding their own code. that said, if you joined more recently, maybe that's more excuseable as it has gotten better, but the lack of research doesn't particularly speak well to your ability to interact with RNS in a "academic manner".
go use meshchatx or sideband.

to be fair to people though, i can understand how getting told every time you try to make or organize something that it's stupid, or doing something wrong could feel upsetting, but maybe ask people before doing? that might limit the backlash. 

finally, this whole thing stinks of corporate and sales pitches. 

open it to the actual public via telepresence and so you can prove your point instead of going "trust me bro"

---

## Reply 23

**oatmilk!** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:31 PM

**flok** wrote:
> @Mark feel free to shoot me a dm at 3139c1fa6446992c97862f2be639bdb9 i'd be more than happy to chat with you about all this and go in a bit more detail that i don't necessarily want to be publicly available

naw dude make it publicly available, you brought this into the open, let's see it stay in the open

---

## Reply 24

**Nickie** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:47 PM

**flok** wrote:
> @Mark feel free to shoot me a dm at 3139c1fa6446992c97862f2be639bdb9 i'd be more than happy to chat with you about all this and go in a bit more detail that i don't necessarily want to be publicly available

Oh yeah, and why's that? There are other Reticulum developers here watching what's going down closely.

---

## Reply 25

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:48 PM

But for the record (regarding Columba) Torlando did handle it all very responsibly and quickly once he found out that things were maybe not too great with the LLM-generated backend, and was very intent from the beginning on being respectful towards everyone on the networks. He then switched back to running RNS. I just want to make sure the above doesn't read as Columba is still having those issues, caus I know Torlando takes it very seriously.

---

## Reply 26

**LadyInGreen** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:49 PM

I would like to mention a couple of things here in case they were not obvious or if people do not click on this groups survey form link.

First of all. The heading here is "Reticulum Developer Summit 2026/27" and it sounds to me like they did not discuss this with Mark or invited him. They create this "summit" over the head of the person who invented and created and maintain Reticulum.

Now look at what you can choose to discuss at this summit:

- A reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers?

If this is not a big red flag waved in front of the developer and maintainer of reticulum I do not know what is! This organization have apparently not submitted one line of code to RNS, and they now take on the role of creating a RETICULUM FOUNDATION to manage and distribute funds! While Mark is not involved at all. For this I have only words too ugly to see the light of day.

Maybe reading these posts would be healthy for anyone supporting this group:
https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/blob/master/This%20Is%20Not%20a%20Teahouse.md
https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/blob/master/docs/history/2026_09_18_Yes_I_am_Angry.md

- Decentralization of development?

The link above apply to this as well...
It is like most people do not take Reticulum serious as all, this is not a game engine where a few glitches do not matter or where someone from the outside can add a strange and unneeded feature. This is a vital communication stack! Why do you want to grant anyone from every street corner the right to mess with this code just because they have a new flashy new shiny untested idea?

- Do you see a need for better coordination within the Reticulum ecosystem?

What is there to be coordinated? Coordinated by who? And what gives them the mandate to coordinate others work?

- Lack of formal specification as a hindrance to interoperability

Mark have already answered about a formal spec here:

https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/tree/master#reference-implementation

- Coordinate Interoperability between diverging implementations

They sure would like to be on top of things it seems...

- Coordinate a uniform and intuitive UI design across software?

Wait what? So they get to mandate how other developers are allowed to make a UI for software that uses or builds on Reticulum?

-  AI development policies

So they want to be on top of this as well... What's wrong with this existing one for example:

https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/blob/master/Contributing.md#machine-assistance--llms

- Do you need financial support to join the meeting?

Oh... I thought they did not have any money and this was purely a volunteer effort?


If this does not sound like a power grab, I do not know what is sounds like...

---

## Reply 27

**LadyInGreen** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:53 PM

Well... it took a while to write that reply and now I see a lot was written here in the meantime.

However the points still stands and I trust people in the community and possible attendees can see this for what it is.

---

## Reply 28

**aetherlab** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:54 PM

**LadyInGreen** wrote:
> 
> If this does not sound like a power grab, I do not know what is sounds like...

Same conclusion, really.
Aaaand now you will be labeled as toxic, just wait 40 seconds more... :D

---

## Reply 29

**oatmilk!** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 8:59 PM

**Mark** wrote:
> But for the record (regarding Columba) Torlando did handle it all very responsibly and quickly once he found out that things were maybe not too great with the LLM-generated backend, and was very intent from the beginning on being respectful towards everyone on the networks. He then switched back to running RNS. I just want to make sure the above doesn't read as Columba is still having those issues, caus I know Torlando takes it very seriously.

yeah i edited it afterwards to try and state that was resolved, but probably could have been more clear in that

---

## Reply 30

**Blastertoad** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 9:14 PM

As someone newer with nothing publicly shared yet, being very generous, there is a good argument for extending formal spec and coordination in the ecosystem. 

There have been multiple posts here about trying to coordinate lora specs for interoperability with no satisfactory conclusions.

New user on-boarding can be tough when installing a chat app leaves the user unconnected and the app in non functioning state without any default interfaces or a wizard guiding setup.

Just finding projects running on rns can be difficult, so now what do I do with this tool beyond chat and tediously try to browse nomadnet overwhelmed by test and hello world pages.

Some more coordination and a matrix or suggested regional spec for wireless interface setting for wider interoperability wouldn't hurt.

The presentation and other topics do raise the question of who are these to suggest a centralized body over a decentralized network.

But also, I would love a world with a bare minimum standard in ui and ux. Lol

---

## Reply 31

**flok** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 9:43 PM

First of all, I don't owe you disclosing personal information. I do not appreciate the tone of aetherlab and oatmilk and don't feel the need for defending or proving myself to you. I'm happy to discuss and answer good faith questions but I'm not gonna engage with whatever strawmanning you have going on here.

I understand that this post has rang many alarm bells for people here. It's written in a very academic language, mentions collaboration with universities and has the word governance in there. I also understand that in the light of many AI slopware clones and attempts at claiming reticulum, an attempt at hostile takeover is not out of the question.

There is no organisation. There's a travelling circus teaching mesh networking to crowds in autonomous communities, largely squats around the netherlands. We've been doing this for a while and have some rapport with those communities and would like to have a moment to meet with those folks, the devs and other users to share experiences and exchange information. Maxigas and lava are both at university, but the rest of the circus isn't uni-connected, at least with reticulum-related stuff. I for instance have never been to uni lol

> They create this "summit" over the head of the person who invented and created and maintain Reticulum.

This post is an invitation for people involved with reticulum, including Mark, to find a moment to meet together and discuss what we'd like to see happen within the mesh. We haven't created anything, lava is asking for input. I understand that it would've been nice to text Mark directly beforehand, but it's not like we're doing something secret here.

> This organization have apparently not submitted one line of code to RNS

So yeah as I said there's no organisation, we're a couple of hackers working together to get reticulum adopted in various places. Submitting code to RNS is not a determinant of involvement, I'm personally not a developer. I'm more skilled and interested in the networking side of things and choose to focus on wi-fi links. 

> and they now take on the role of creating a RETICULUM FOUNDATION to manage and distribute funds! While Mark is not involved at all.

No foundation is being established. Mark should get paid for the labor he's putting in RNS, and he's invited, as are you and everyone else reading this to discuss this. Also, nobody is after your money. Getting a nonprofit running could make it easier to apply for funding or donations and pay the devs for their hard work.

> This is a vital communication stack! Why do you want to grant [...]

ok this is a strawman

> Wait what? So they get to mandate how other developers are allowed to make a UI for [...]

same as above

> Oh... I thought they did not have any money and this was purely a volunteer effort?

yeah it's called either
1) throwing in 15€ each and paying for a train ticket for someone.
2) using the university connections to try and get a budget to pay people's train tickets if they can't afford to come.


All I'm asking for here is a little bit of charitability in interpretations. It seems like a lot of you have read this and imagined the worst possible thing. The reality is a bit more nuanced than this. This is an attempt at getting people together to strenghten the mesh and try and find ways to collaborate. I'll be happy to answer more tomorrow.

I hope this can be approached with more curiosity and less defensiveness, even if it initially tripped a bunch of alarm bells.

---

## Reply 32

**oatmilk!** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 10:09 PM

**Blastertoad** wrote:
> As someone newer with nothing publicly shared yet, being very generous, there is a good argument for extending formal spec and coordination in the ecosystem. 
> 
> There have been multiple posts here about trying to coordinate lora specs for interoperability with no satisfactory conclusions.

as one of the people trying to work on this the nature of mesh networks is a mix of first to publish, and "it depends locally" that said, the default configuration was nonfunctional for at least one implementation when i was testing it. it would be nice to have this resolved (and it may have been! this was like 4 months ago), but i do not think that this summet would be helpful for that. 

> New user on-boarding can be tough when installing a chat app leaves the user unconnected and the app in non functioning state without any default interfaces or a wizard guiding setup.

respectfully, rtfm. it goes over how to bootstrap

> Just finding projects running on rns can be difficult, so now what do I do with this tool beyond chat and tediously try to browse nomadnet overwhelmed by test and hello world pages.

the solution you're looking for is either a webring (which rns.recipes/nomadnet provides) or the amber pages node or similar (which acts as a phonebook for nomadnet pages) both of these exist, but better metadata could be added for the amber pages site 

> Some more coordination and a matrix or suggested regional spec for wireless interface setting for wider interoperability wouldn't hurt.

we had a matrix, which was a hive of unproductive behavior and arguments. it has been replaced by this forum which is arguably better.

> The presentation and other topics do raise the question of who are these to suggest a centralized body over a decentralized network.

> But also, I would love a world with a bare minimum standard in ui and ux. Lol

the bare minimum standards is "does it actually have a ui that works"

---

## Reply 33

**Blastertoad** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 10:23 PM

> respectfully, rtfm. it goes over how to bootstrap
> 

I feel end users should rarely be required to read technical spec. But this will be up to each project dev.
 
> we had a matrix, which was a hive of unproductive behavior and arguments. it has been replaced by this forum which is arguably better.
> 
For clarity I am talking about the data structure, not chat platform. So a if in this country these public backbones are know to use these settings so radios can link up.

---

## Reply 34

**Zenith** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 10:26 PM

There is a fundamental disconnect between this fantastical vision of a "Reticulum Committee" and *the actual underlying software itself*.

We're long past the point of symbol decay. To the OP of this post, what does "Reticulum" mean to you? Is it the reference implementation?  Or is it just a blanket buzzword for some vague idea of something that sounds nice?

All of the things you  list can be done without coordination, and without any central authority. If that's the design goal of Reticulum, shouldn't the "governance" model follow suit?

You don't need to ask someone's permission to go put up a LoRa node on your balcony.

You don't need permission to go give a talk at your local ham club or hackerspace to find other people to do the same.

You don't need permission to go write a LXMF client.

All of these things can be done, today, without any "committee" existing. 

 It's much easier to sit around all day thinking about ways to "govern" a project than it is to do any actual constructive work.

You (or someone else) have done this several times already. Back when we used the Element, you would come in here, drop a link, and then dip.

You didn't write the software. You didn't design it. You pretend like it just popped out of thin air one day, basically giving the finger to the guy who is responsible for the thing you are trying to "govern". 

Organizing workshops and talks is awesome, but to act like that's the point of contention here is disingenuous. You can organize a talk without a central governing authority. 

Bureaucracy is the death knell of open source software. If you would like it to take 20 years to add image previews to a file picker, the "Governance" model is the way to go.

---

## Reply 35

**oatmilk!** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 10:37 PM

**Blastertoad** wrote:
> I feel end users should rarely be required to read technical spec. But this will be up to each project dev.


if you CBA to read a 18 page quick start guide, that is genuinely your own issue. understanding how to work software that you have downloaded should be a bare minimum bar to entry. 

> For clarity I am talking about the data structure, not chat platform. So a if in this country these public backbones are know to use these settings so radios can link up.

again, that is a local issue and not a global one, and should be decided by the first person or group to make a ***functional*** LORA backbone for their area, similar to how meshtastic or meshcore work.

---

## Reply 36

**Zenith** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 11:10 PM

I can't put this all into one post, but we are fundamentally undergoing a *crisis of agency*. The reason software like Reticulum exists in the first place is the result of this.

We are dependent on a system in which we have no autonomy in. Most people aren't even aware of this. 

The ever-growing digital panopticon that runs your life doesn't give you any say. You are a data point for corporate and government interests. The very nature of communication has become a privilege. 

Reticulum is not a panacea. It's cool stuff, but not a cure-all. I'm a realist and I'm not going to pretend like it will ever replace the bulk of the Internet. But it is a tool to restore *agency*

To the "governance people": I really want you to consider a few things. 

Break down what this project is to first principles and start from there.

Is your time really best spent writing some bullshit 50 page charter for how to run a Python project? Or is it better allocated towards something more important, with a broader impact, like educating people on the nature of the current landscape of our technological nightmare?

I would encourage you to look into what Louis Rossmann is doing with the FULU foundation and the Consumer Rights Wiki if you want a template on effective strategies. 

Second, what would a "governance committee" accomplish? In what way would it benefit Reticulum - as it exists today? Most OSS "foundations" have become maligned with corporate interests leading to rapid enshittification. Reticulum, and Mark don't have a corporate sponsor. All of the funding I have seen comes from individual, single-dollar donors. 

As I said in the post above, you can do everything you've listed without any formal organization, right now, today. You haven't raised any argument as to why this is needed.

Would forming one magically make all of the issues of "bad UX" go away? Would there suddenly be dozens of people jumping to work and maintain the codebase for free? Would we see a planetary wide Reticulum network all thanks to the effort of someone I've never even seen outside of posting links to their "governance meetings"? 

Those are my thoughts, and you are welcome to disagree. But you are doing something that is fundamentally an incorrect approach to solve a problem that doesn't exist. At the same time there are many problems worth solving.

---

## Reply 37

**Mark** · Wed, Nov 18, 2026 11:16 PM

To what Zenith just wrote, I can only say that I fully concur, and could not have put it better myself.

---

## Reply 38

**bettertaste** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 12:14 AM

@mark, I joined because I am in and around the reticulum community here in NL, play with reticulum and I help out new comers at workshops with basics. 

A friend said something along the lines of WTF is happening on the reticulum forum re: this event (it is a small and big community) and why are they taking pot shots at community workshops I have attended. Looking at your responses I can see the many tangible reasons you may be upset and I hope you or maxigas will reach out to each other as I continue to think you should just chat (I am *not* him to be 100% clear!).

To start, I am deeply appreciative for what you have given us and I hope we can chat in person one day. I do want to highlight a few things as I think it is important tbh (as a new comer). First you said:

> what parts of my writing here do you consider vitriol, exactly?

I think you misunderstood. I think @decentral1se was referring to @aetherlab not you. See these comments:

- "if this isn't a classic grant-eater... The **utter bullshit of this description** reminds me of the **fart of politics** for the last 50 years - absolute Tavistock talk!!!" - I couldn't find out what Tavistock talk is, but from a search I am guessing it refers to a UK consulting firm working in finance
- "THIS ONE I BEAUTIFUL TOO! The pillars of understanding!!!"
- "If no one peddles bullshit"
- "the moment we smell the foul stench of this type of BS, **the shovel flips and they are met with the fat end of the handle**"

I suppose our standard to evaluate this should be the zen of reticulum which asks for constructive response which: "is one that is proportionate, and does not cost the community its resources, sanity and dignity: Engage the content once, on its merits (if any), with evidence, in public, and then refer to the existing records."

My own view is that sarcasm, ridiculing people, and using violent metaphors are not a constructive nor proportionate way to respond to an **intern** (see the end of the post). I personally think worse off of this community for it. I am not like "fuck those guys, I never want to engage again" but it does not scream people who will respond kindly to my questions even if I have seen this community being good elsewhere in other threads.

The problem is that the moderator sets the tone so then we then get a response from someone else stating:

> culturally enforced moral ocd hellhole that is Tumblr, fuck off with the "oh you're being so mean to me and the minorities who I'm speaking for".

Although I try to read it with the benefit of the doubt, and text is basically miscommunication, I think that this is not politically middle of the road (as claimed) more or less speaks for itself.

And fwiw: that is not what was said and no one was claiming to represent anyone. As I read the comment (paraphrasing): we are being accused of getting rich off workshops, but we are doing it for free helping people who are getting the short of the stick by society and it is painful to hear people saying we are just being greedy. 

I might not agree with everything in @ladyingreen's post, but I hope the organisers of the summit think through some of their critiques as I can more clearly understand where the bad feelings come from.

Second, you say: 

> You put that into my mouth with silly comments like that, @bettertaste.

Then

> No, that is exactly the opposite of what I am doing. I targeted only one person with that remark - the guy who is actually, very clearly making his living on grants.

But you said: 

> But, FYI, academia, "the grantiverse" and universities (especially) is a **multi-million bussiness**, in case you somehow missed the news.

Here you seem to implicitly suggest that anyone receiving grants or in academia may be getting millions personally. Some do, but most not as far as I know. I think we both misunderstood each other at first but now maybe get where we are coming from so I do not want to waste more time on it unless you think it is interesting to discuss.

Anyway, to shift to a more interesting point. 

One thing that looks from afar like a point of confusion/disagreement in this thread is who are reticulum developers? I have no idea who will be at this summit, but if the line is: only people who develop the core protocol than I suspect maybe not many or any - I have no idea. 

There are many people in NL playing with adapting things to microcontrollers etc. There are things I want to play around re: micron syntax highlighting for text-editors or color drawing unicode in micron or maybe little nomadnet apps for sharing music or something. I do not have the academic or self-taught background (I have no idea how you got there) or brains to do the things you do. A technology that is amazing still needs people who are bringing content to it and using it in creative ways. I don't read this thread to be gate-keeping what is a reticulum developer in that way, but it does read as though the foundations is the main point of reference and I think it is worth keeping in mind that a broader group of people exists who do "reticulum development" but not with that specific competence as the core people and perhaps it will seem less like a power grab seen in that light - I dunno.

I have no idea who will be there - I am curious about this gathering because people I know will be there who I like, who do cool things, and have a good sense of who is speaking bullshit themselves and I have not looked further at the program etc.

Again, thanks for hopefully reading this far @mark and again I appreciate what you have done and continue to do. Perhaps one day we chat in person - then I could tell you in great detail how much I appreciated the anti-military and fuck off LLM clauses in the license! I think the responses to it are important a wake up call to do more like it as the clauses themselves.

---

## Reply 39

**oatmilk!** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 12:41 AM

**bettertaste** wrote:
> [...]

the middle of the road comment is specifically a "hey I'm not exclusively going to dog on people for trying to organize an event", and honestly, i am far too tired to spend time on niceities when responding to people specifically trying to have a victim complex. 
you should note when there was constructive criticism to give, i have done so. 


seeing as i'm getting downvoted i should mention that i was talking about someone mirroring their bandcamp to the 'ret

as for who is the devs, mark is specifically the BDFL of the python reference implementation, as well as nomadnet and he was not informed about this "summet" until this forum post, hence his rightful indignation about this whole deal. 

> There are things I want to play around re: micron syntax highlighting for text-editors or color drawing unicode in micron or maybe little nomadnet apps for sharing music or something. 

iirc these are all things that exist, but having a "today in the ret'" thread or something for people to share and discuss cool things they've seen on nomadnet could be useful, if it doesn't get hijacked by people shilling slop. also perhaps look at the manual, which shows off some cool projects 

if the syntax highlighting isn't out there yet, you can look at existing syntax highlighting standards, and spend time writing your own (by hand please, it's not hard) and then put it in showcase. honestly if you don't do that, i might give it a shot for notepad++ since that's what i use.

---

## Reply 40

**Adingbatponder** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 7:28 AM

Just wanted to say that FOSS tends to go like this. Chill.

It is a remarkable achievement by Mark to create a tool/service/idea/concept that triggers others to jump on board with such whole-hearted gusto. This is because reticulum is a concept for its time: the time of privacy destruction and information theft. 

I am all my life confronted with people who have good and (what I see as) bad ideas or behaviours. What defines humanity and social living is to focus on the good and deal non-destructively with the bad e.g. ignore, avoid, steer, engage, forgive, laugh, shrug. And note that one can have more in common than differences.

Reticulum and nomadnet pages are the only currently viable tools to regain what the information age was supposed to be for: communication in private by the people for the people. Reticulum gives the finger to tech bros' business model based on data theft and profiling and to hostile governments and their three letter agencies that seek to damage democracy. It is a Nobel Peace Prize level of significace long-run as it solves a problem at the core of Big Brother type abuse of our tech.

This is why it receives academic interest, and that is part of the way society has evolved to develop knowledge. If there is one thing worse than being talked about: it is not being talked about.

---

## Reply 41

**aetherlab** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 9:39 AM

Oh, very eloquent! :) Laid out well. "Concept of it's time" is a nice anchor, and "whole-hearted gusto" truly brings lightness to it, and all of this in a single sentence! 
I think we have another professor here!
And than comes the payload...
"What defines humanity and social living is to focus on the good and deal non-destructively with the bad e.g. ignore, avoid, steer, engage, forgive, laugh, shrug."
1) "What defines humanity and social living is..." That is thick. Every human, society and culture derives these definitions for themselves. What's with the all encompassing approach? This is not what defines humanity for me, and for many more.
2) Face away from the bad and do not focus on it. Bad is a constant, bad is all prevailing. Typical western construct, placing evil on a level, that is unreachable for humans, and placing good on the level of plain tradeoff - something to give away, to earn, to buy and sell. In my culture, Slavic one, we place good on that next level and accept evil as something within reach of all good men. In our tales we either destroy it, chase it away (search кукери online) or strike a deal with it, so it behaves. But we don't face away, ignore, avoid, forgive, or, God forbid - shrug at it. 
3) "It is a Nobel Peace Prize level of significace long-run as it solves a problem at the core of Big Brother type abuse of our tech." Oh, you also have feathers in that pocket! If we put aside the fact what Nobel invented and lived off and how many of those prizes were given off to people I would not associate any kind of peace with, RNS does not solve any problem by itself, like any other tool. People using it properly and in good will does. So this, if we read the words like gospel, is pointed in the wrong direction. But not really, is it? It is not meant to signify anything, it is meant to flatter Mark, and has a very nice counterweight, in the form of "Big Brother".
4) "Reticulum gives the finger to tech bros' business model based on data theft and profiling and to hostile governments and their three letter agencies that seek to damage democracy."
Oh, we have the whole package here!!! IT'S A BINGOOOOOU!!! We have the revolutionary call of Finger-Giving, the diminution of "tech bros'", the lack of comma after "model", that would just interrupt the flow of joy, the "true differentiation" between capital and state, between tech-business-data theft cluster and government-agency, the wild sin of democracy-damaging! This is a whole-milk-milk-shake! Very Hollywood-Tavistock vibey, joy to chew on and swallow. Most people tend to forget, that the Demos, that Kratos the masses in a Democracy, are not "THE PEOPLE", they were the citizens, the slave and land owners, in short THE OWNERS. They rule. They are the SUBJECT. All others are AN OBJECT.
And this is why it is sooo aloowed to talk about ANYTHING ELSE but about ownership. God forbid PERSONAL one.
5) Academia is nowhere to be found here. Interest comes from a very different vector. One that is well fed, supplied, informed and organized. And disruptive.
6) "(what I see as) bad..." ah relativity rules...

But overall - amazing! We haven't had such text since the forum is up. It is on another level. Kudos! :)

---

## Reply 42

**gabuzo** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 10:06 AM

I am surprised that nobody mentioned yet that at the bottom of https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are the logo of the Ford Foundation and the Open Technology Fund, who for its entire first years was 100% staffed with personnel from Radio Free Asia, itself funded by the US "Broadcasting Board of Governors" and previously 100% operated directly by the CIA... This may be seen as an even more disturbing interference than "just" power grab.

---

## Reply 43

**Rudi Mentaire** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 10:36 AM

My thoughts here are: It is, at least from the perspective of what I have read here, really, objectively irritating, how the organisers of this event failed, and fail, to coordinate with a big part of the community and the main developers, given the subjects they want to handle. But ok, I only have this perspective, maybe my impression is wrong.

But apart from that - isn't this already partly a discussion about the things that this conference is about? With a very relevant part of the community involved? Dear organisers, you should be able to handle this discussion here, because this is _exactly_ what a relevant discussion just might look like.

And if you like to invite anyone, it is (at least in my world) _your_ task to make people curious. It is typically not something one demands. Anyway, I'm afraid so far you have not been able to dispel some justified concerns of this important part of the community. And no, it is not due to academic language. It is, for example, calling valid concerns "strawman". I have, really, I'm quite new here, but I really have not the best impression, your invitation and the way it was presented here just were at least irritating. The reactions you got may be very sharp, but they are understandable.

---

## Reply 44

**aetherlab** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 10:39 AM

**gabuzo** wrote:
> I am surprised that nobody mentioned yet that at the bottom of https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are the logo of the Ford Foundation and the Open Technology Fund, who for its entire first years was 100% staffed with personnel from Radio Free Asia, itself funded by the US "Broadcasting Board of Governors" and previously 100% operated directly by the CIA... This may be seen as an even more disturbing interference than "just" power grab.

Aaaaaaaaaa damn iiit!!! You outran me on this one haha! Cheers for the vigilance! 
This is a very well funded nest of vipers and a classical informational warfare outfit and has to be taken very seriously.

---

## Reply 45

**zenith_2m_vhf_mobile** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 11:20 AM

>  This is why it receives academic interest, and that is part of the way society has  This is why it receives academic interest, and that is part of the way society has  evolved to develop knowledge. 

Please go back and read the last two pages, that is not the issue here

---

## Reply 46

**Mees electronics** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 11:36 AM

I live in a small village and we know our neighbors. We greet, talk and help each other out where needed. One day, a new neighbor moved in and on that first day she visited all the houses in the street. Not to introduce herself, but to tell us that she had started a whatsapp group for the neighborhood and we should all participate. We were flabbergasted and politely declined her offer. We told her that she could, instead, always knock on our door or call us if needed. We never heard from her again. 

Should she have taken the time to get to know the local community first, I think things could have gone differently.

---

## Reply 47

**Nickie** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 2:46 PM

**Rudi Mentaire** wrote:
> But ok, I only have this perspective, maybe my impression is wrong.
> 
They are just looking to discover/pinpoint/recruit more "fellows" that may be sympathetic to their cause and sufficiently versed in the inner workings of RNS to establish their foothold here.

---

## Reply 48

**gabuzo** · Thu, Nov 19, 2026 3:38 PM

**aetherlab** wrote:
> **gabuzo** wrote:
> > I am surprised that nobody mentioned yet that at the bottom of https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are the logo of the Ford Foundation and the Open Technology Fund, who for its entire first years was 100% staffed with personnel from Radio Free Asia, itself funded by the US "Broadcasting Board of Governors" and previously 100% operated directly by the CIA... This may be seen as an even more disturbing interference than "just" power grab.
> 
> Aaaaaaaaaa damn iiit!!! You outran me on this one haha! Cheers for the vigilance! 
> This is a very well funded nest of vipers and a classical informational warfare outfit and has to be taken very seriously.

It has actually been the primary tactic of the Open Technology Fund in the past: to gather all actors in one field, usually in a nice hotel on a beach resort (so as an extra benefit you have them leaving their laptops and other cryptographic material in their hotel room ;))) ) to have them to socialize, to get to trust you and to better exert "soft power" on them by infusing money and then only orally telling them "but don't work on this" or "do insist on such and such"...

Have you noted how no group working on "censorship", "internet filtering", etc. funded by the OTF has never named the USA as a main actor of Internet censorship, under the guise of copyright, code of conducts and other morality clause of a Google, Meta, Twitter. etc.?

It's almost a digression... but is it?

---
