# On the CriticalInfraLab's invitation to a "Reticulum Developer Summit"

_General · started by LadyInGreen (web) on Fri, Nov 20, 2026 10:53 PM_

---

## Original post

**LadyInGreen (web)** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 10:53 PM

I have decided to create a new thread regarding the [invitation to "Reticulum Developer Summit 2026/27" arranged by CriticalInfraLab](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reticulum-developer-summit-202627).

Looking through the original (very long) thread, it is clear that two groups are on two parallel tracks, each accusing each other of unrelated things.

1. People are defending workshops and good initiatives around them arranged by CriticalInfraLab (unrelated to the summit invitation) and feel that the good volunteering work they do is being critisiced + they are frustrated with the tone in this forum.
2. People are concerned about the real agenda of this summit based on the topics listed in their survey form.

Several times it has been pointed out that the topics listed in the [survey form](https://files.criticalinfralab.net/apps/forms/embed/wwbACJrmSfJ5f4t8GQCAN8M9) for this summit is the **actual** problem! 

**Nobody** here is criticizing the workshops or other work happening. There was a slight concern at first but after @flok, @tyise and @bettertaste described what was going down in these workshops Mark explicitly said: "@flok, so what you describe there sounds perfectly awesome, and incredibly helpful."

I want to thank @Zenith for the [great description of the actual issue](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reticulum-developer-summit-202627?page=2#post-4131), it was very much to the point, I will take the liberty to add your reply to this thread as well, let's try to keep the topic focused this time.

---

## Reply 1

**LadyInGreen (web)** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 10:54 PM

Now to briefly talk about this frustration of the tone of some participants:

The supporters of this summit seems to think it is perfectly OK to be rude in the rudest of manners if you do it with a nice language. However if you call out this rudeness in harsh language it is very hurtful and toxic.

This "developer summit" invitation lists these topics for discussion:

- *decentralization of development* - This could only point to RNS itself, as everything else is already 100% decentralized, so essentially calling for Mark's removal as main maintainer.
- *a reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers* - **Without** ever contacting the active inventer/creator/maintainer of the network-stack to discuss this.

I mean how absolutely rude can it get? I really understand why main developers and the community is upset about this! Mark spend 10+ years creating and sharing this amazing tech with us. I cannot imagine the mental strain of seeing tings like this pop up out of nowhere again and again in different formats. It is not the first time something like this is coming from this "critical infrastructure lab".

But, if you call out this rudeness with some none accepted words you are toxic. And if you try to point out the insanity of it there is no real replies to the criticism raised.

[I read sentences like](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reticulum-developer-summit-202627?page=2#post-4136):

- "**why are they taking pot shots at community workshops I have attended**" - *nobody took shots at community workshops!*
- "**we are being accused of getting rich off workshops, but we are doing it for free helping people who are getting the short of the stick by society and it is painful to hear people saying we are just being greedy.**" *- nobody said that you get rich of workshops!* - 
	Mark stated that "academia, "the grantiverse" and universities (especially) is a **multi-million bussiness**". 
	This is now flipped upside down through a black hole and now means: "people doing voluntary workshops are greedy" ??? - no wonder the communication goes ascrew.

This is the real poison being poured here (in a nice language), and this poison has the ability to sink deep... Imagine the rifts this creates in the global community as a whole. How many people in the local NL communities have now been told that at rns.recipies people are attacking them for doing voluntary workshops. How many of these people will actually go back to source and to check this absurd claim! How many will just repeat it deepening the rift?

I see this as an actual toxic outcome of this. People in a Reticulum group in NL think their workshops are being criticized, and of course they do not understand it and now we have an actual divide between people that was completely unnecessary!

At the same time I want to point out that some of the regulars here were also quite a bit over the top, and we should all mind how we speak to each other!

Everybody seems to miss the point that **nobody** as in **nobody!** have been criticizing any community workshops! What has been criticized is the topics to be discussed at this "Reticulum Developer Summit" dropping down from the middle nowhere with the main topics pointing to governance of Reticulum, and **none** of the main developers have been involved or informed!

---

## Reply 2

**LadyInGreen (web)** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 10:56 PM

Here is the list of topics for the summit, (please no more talk of workshops):

![reticulum_summit.png](/storage/forum/2VfOFPkl1iYy4QJWkKDz4AO93m7FZMNR5GCUXA57.png)

This summit is arranged by https://www.criticalinfralab.net/. They are funded by:
- Ford Foundation
- Internet Society Foundation
- Open Technology Fund
- AI Collaborative
- NWO

Two official donations to the lab I could find:
- [Ford Foundation, US$350,000](https://web.archive.org/web/20260715171620/https://www.fordfoundation.org/work/our-grants/awarded-grants/grants-database/university-of-amsterdam-144895/) - "Core support for the Critical Infrastructure Lab to research and develop evidence-based policy for the creation of a more equitable digital infrastructure"
- [Internet Society Foundation, US$250,000](https://www.isocfoundation.org/project/the-critical-infrastructure-lab/) - "How does internet infrastructure reconfigure power relationships and resource dependencies, and how could it better serve the public interest?" ... "This research produces concrete recommendations for governments, industry, civil society, and governance bodies."

One of their board members:
[Michael Brennan](https://michaelbrennan.work/): "I recently completed a full term at Ford Foundation as a Senior Program Officer with the [Technology and Society](https://www.fordfoundation.org/work/challenging-inequality/technology-and-society/) team. I managed a global $125M grantmaking portfolio on public interest technology, artificial intelligence, cybersecurity, infrastructure, and more. I also developed and led the Technology Fellows program to transform the institution’s ability to integrate technology expertise into all areas of work."

Maxigas who co-runs this lab held a workshop at the [39th Chaos Communications Congress](https://events.ccc.de/congress/2025/hub/en/event/detail/reticulum-workshop-3-politics-of-the-reticulum-eco#):
> Reticulum workshop #3: Politics of the Reticulum Ecosystem
> Which are the political choices and fault lines in the technology and the community around it? What are the consequences? How to improve the situation? Can we find a normative common ground? Is that necessary? If so, why?

They run this website, launched in May 2026:
https://reticulum.community/
It started out as an exact clone of the official reticulum.network site, but was then later changed with this wording:

"This is the new website for the Reticulum community. The idea is to provide a fresher and friendlier portal to people seeking information about the protocol than the usual entry point at [https://reticulum.network/](https://reticulum.network/). That includes tracking changes happening there and putting them in the context of the wider Reticulum ecosystem."

Maxigas from CriticalInfraLab facilitates monthly Reticulum calls, [here is the poster](https://radar.squat.net/en/event/amsterdam/lag/2026-06-05/reticulum-community-videocall-no5-june) from the one in June:

![flyer_9.jpg](/storage/forum/RHXjlYTKzsSeo7kZO53k9golN4JDXpLBvhqdkobO.jpg)

Big label "**Governance debate**" on the poster!

An interesting sub note: They have "beechat" on the poster as well, and reticulum.community itself mentions "drone control" as a capability with reticulum.

[Beechat Network Systems Ltd](https://beechat.network/company/) - A commercial company developing Reticulum-rs (Rust implementation) and rns-mavlink-rs for drone C2. They sell military equipment using their Reticulum implementation as transport and [they now partner with NATO](https://beechat.network/2026/01/26/kicking-off-nato-diana-from-defence-innovation-to-operational-deployment/)
Beechat have been very straightforward about their goal to produce military tech for commercial sales for more than a year, they have not been hiding their intentions. CriticalInfraLab and Maxigas seems to endorse this effort.

I am wondering if they ever invited Mark to discuss Reticulum in any of their Global Reticulum calls. If you take your time to read this Mark, I would be interested to know if you were ever contacted by this group of if they invited you to answer questions on one of their calls?


Ok, so for an outsider, it very much look like Maxigas and https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are looking to gain some influence/governance over the Reticulum project.

I am open to being wrong here, but the [response so far to critical questions asked have been none existent](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reticulum-developer-summit-202627).

---

## Reply 3

**LadyInGreen (web)** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 10:57 PM

So to @flok and the people arranging this summit, please take your time and actually answer these questions regarding the proposed points:

- Do you see a need for better coordination within the Reticulum ecosystem?
*What kind of coordination are you talking about here?* 
*What real outcome do you expect form this discussion?* 
*Who would you like to see being the coordinator?*

- default settings for LoRa radio
This is very much location dependent, different countries have different legislation for this. Creating default settings is a very bad idea. People should not use this if they cannot figure out the frequencies for their local area.
*Why do you want to mandate default settings?*

- decentralization of development
*Is the development of application and the ecosystem around reticulum not already completely decentralized?* 
*I can only read this as pointed to the core RNS development, or have I misunderstood something?*
*By listing this, the arrangers clearly see an issue here. What **actual** problem is it you seek to solve?*
*How do you envision decentralization of RNS development?
If the concern is Mark as sole main maintainer, why not talk with him in a colatabral manner, instead of dumping this without his knowledge?* 

- the lack of formal specification as a hindrance to interoperability
Mark has already stated that the reference implementation **is** the spec, and it is currently still evolving, stamps has just been added in several key areas.
Further we have [this reply](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/brandolinis-reference-or-alternatively-agentsmd?page=1#post-3005) from Mark detailing what a formal speck would entitle.
*What kind of outcome do you expect from this discussion?* 
*Why is the RNS implemtation (in python, easy code reading for everyone) not enough?*
*By listing this, the arrangers clearly see an issue here. What **actual** problem is it you seek to solve?*
*Why do we at this point need more implementation, in the light that RNS is still being actively developed and we already have microReticulum and ReticulumGO?*

 - coordinate interoperability between diverging implementations
*Who is going to coordinate this in the light that core RNS developers are **not** invited to speak at the summit?
Why do we need **diverging** implementations?
Why do they need to interoperate while diverging from the RNS reference implementation?
Why would this be a good thing for the mesh network as a whole?*

- coordinate uniform and intuitive UI design across software
I'm very curious about this one!
*Why do we need **uniform** UI design across software? 
Who will benefit from this?
Who will be responsible for this coordination and lay out the guidelines?
Do you envision this to be mandated for software building on the Reticulum network stack?*

- a reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers
*Why is this a topic of the summit?
Why has core RNS developers not been involved? 
Why are core RNS developers not invited to speak at your summit if you are discussion the establishment of a Reticulum Foundation?
Why do you think it is OK for a third party, not involved with RNS development, do discuss a reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds?
Who do you envision at the top of this foundation (Mark is not involved so it cannot be him)?
With this as a topic for discussion, how could you say this summit is "not at all about money"?
Who will distribute the funds?*
The organizers of this summit put this point of discussion for a reason, and they did it **without** any contact with main RNS developers! I would like to know what the real agenda is here!

- AI development policies
*Why and where do the initiators of this summit disagree with current guidelines in the Reticulum manual?
If you do disagree, why is this added as a main topic at the summit?*

I see 6/9 of the topics is related to governance of the reticulum community + developers. 
*Why is 67% of the topics listed for this summit of governance related topics?
Why is governance the most important topic of this "developer summit"?*

When this thread was first created there was a point on the survey specifically talking about governance.
*Why was this point removed from your submit form?*

Given the topics of this summit, especially about the creation of a Reticulum Foundation and interoperability between diverging implementation:
*Why was Mark not invited as a main speaker to this summit? 
Why is he only invited as an attendee?*

I think it is fair to say that if this summit was presented with topics of what you describe is happening in the workshops, all would be nice and fine. However this does not seem to be the case.

---

## Reply 4

**LadyInGreen (web)** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 10:57 PM

In the past there have been several people who have been calling for "removing Mark form the equation", people who want to be his replacement and spewing out a lot of garbage about how the Reticulum project need governance and freedom from core developers.

Seeing the points for discussion at this summit, it points more towards the direction of governance and powergrab, and not at all in the direction of developing infrastructure and helping the community grow.

And now you come waltzing in with "*a reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers*" and "*decentralization of development* " and cannot understand why people get **very** upset?

Again I highly encourage you to read through a bit of what has been happening, these are again good starters to see the root of this issue:
[This is not a Teahouse](https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/blob/master/This%20Is%20Not%20a%20Teahouse.md)
[Yes I am Angry](https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/blob/master/docs/history/2026_09_18_Yes_I_am_Angry.md)
[Bandolini's reference](https://github.com/markqvist/Reticulum/blob/master/docs/markdown/brandolinis.md) ... this is a long read, but worth it.

I think Marks tone here in all his replies are **very** respectful considering the big red flag this "developer summit" is waving in his face the same day as RNS 1.6.1 is out and he must have been working himself to exhaustion with this incredible response to the apparent bot swarm attacks on the network in the recent week. And I hear no one engaging with the response posted by Zenith.

---

## Reply 5

**LadyInGreen (web)** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 11:07 PM

Zenith's response to this "summit" invitation:

> I can't put this all into one post, but we are fundamentally undergoing a crisis of agency. The reason software like Reticulum exists in the first place is the result of this.
>
>
> We are dependent on a system in which we have no autonomy in. Most people aren't even aware of this.
>
>
> The ever-growing digital panopticon that runs your life doesn't give you any say. You are a data point for corporate and government interests. The very nature of communication has become a privilege.
>
>
> Reticulum is not a panacea. It's cool stuff, but not a cure-all. I'm a realist and I'm not going to pretend like it will ever replace the bulk of the Internet. But it is a tool to restore agency
>
>
> To the "governance people": I really want you to consider a few things.
>
>
> Break down what this project is to first principles and start from there.
>
> Is your time really best spent writing some bullshit 50 page charter for how to run a Python project? Or is it better allocated towards something more important, with a broader impact, like educating people on the nature of the current landscape of our technological nightmare?
>
> I would encourage you to look into what Louis Rossmann is doing with the FULU foundation and the Consumer Rights Wiki if you want a template on effective strategies.
>
> Second, what would a "governance committee" accomplish? In what way would it benefit Reticulum - as it exists today? Most OSS "foundations" have become maligned with corporate interests leading to rapid enshittification. Reticulum, and Mark don't have a corporate sponsor. All of the funding I have seen comes from individual, single-dollar donors.
>
> As I said in the post above, you can do everything you've listed without any formal organization, right now, today. You haven't raised any argument as to why this is needed.
>
> Would forming one magically make all of the issues of "bad UX" go away? Would there suddenly be dozens of people jumping to work and maintain the codebase for free? Would we see a planetary wide Reticulum network all thanks to the effort of someone I've never even seen outside of posting links to their "governance meetings"?
>
> Those are my thoughts, and you are welcome to disagree. But you are doing something that is fundamentally an incorrect approach to solve a problem that doesn't exist. At the same time there are many problems worth solving.

---

## Reply 6

**aetherlab** · Fri, Nov 20, 2026 11:22 PM

Thanks for laying down your thoughts, LadyInGreen.
I think with Mark's last post the topic has been exhausted, and so are we.
As I do not wish to see this thread become a conduit of what got the other one locked for in the first place, please check what I wrote here - https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reticulum-developer-summit-202627?page=3#post-4239

---

## Reply 7

**Zenith** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 12:03 AM

i,t's also worth nothing that none of this exists in a vacuum. this pattern of behavior has been continuous over the last 2 years, which is why the "Movement of a Dozen" writing exists in the first place. 


to someone who just reads the summit thread missing the overall context, they may get an idea that the responses were provoked out of nothing. that there is a climate of hostility and "toxic behavior" ingrained in the forum.

this manufactured friction is the result of constant attempts to coup the project. people who will write literal hit pieces against the developer, usually laden with their own bias or motivation. 

for example, Lew Palm, the author of a 100% LLM generated Rust "clone", wrote this article "Killing Reticulum to Save It"
https://archive.ph/Cwel4

in case you think that is my own subjective interpretation, this article is followed up with (yes this is the verbatim title): "How I Learned to Stop Worrying and love the LLM"
https://archive.ph/DYkLE

then, a few months later, another hit piece by another individual, with connections to Lew. with the same outline of "we need to eject Mark as the developer and form our own governance committee :tm:" 
https://archive.ph/vWM9G

this is psychologically and mentally draining. a constant war of attrition against the developer with the end goal to make Mark just say "fuck it, why even bother" and hand over the project to someone else. 

I don't know Maxigas's intentions. When we had the Matrix channel, he would pop into the chat, drop a link + an image (the one in the thread here with the "governance debate" MSpaint wordart) and then dip. there was zero  participation otherwise. 

while I think it's a bit far-fetched and silly to say it's some 5-Eyes intelligence op, I don't blame anyone for coming to that conclusion when this behavior is so persistent, seeming at times almost coordinated.

---

## Reply 8

**iamGBOX** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 12:04 AM

Man, my career focus is in governance, and whenever the claim of "Reticulum needs governance" comes up, it seems pretty laughable and suspicious.

The core function of governance is to ensure the safe, documented, replicable development and environments to limit the possibility of unpredictable behaviour. Making the canonical release the spec, particularly with the clarity and care of release notes, serves this function well, at least for the time being. If someone has a contention with some part of the implementation or documentation, they have full freedom to make a pull request or publish documentation themselves.

RNS has been gaining fantastic ground in the last few years, but there's still so much further to go where adoption and exploring real-world use is concerned. It's not yet a system-critical component for public or private operations, as far as I'm aware, and if it is, the groups using it damn well better be putting their resources behind it's development.

---

## Reply 9

**oatmilk!** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 12:34 AM

**LadyInGreen (web)** wrote:

> - default settings for LoRa radio
> This is very much location dependent, different countries have different legislation for this. Creating default settings is a very bad idea. People should not use this if they cannot figure out the frequencies for their local area.
> *Why do you want to mandate default settings?*

as one of the people to say something that would even remotely suggest that this is good, i think i should probably pipe up and note my issue is that the default.. polling rate? i think?? for the rnode software was set way too high and was hard locking ESP32s for upwards of 5 min while the CPU was pegged at 100, and the link generated better the two was unusable. 
if this is still an issue, it can be solved by a git report or otherwise, and does not need actual governace to fix

as far as bitching about wanting a standard, i believe it may be due to finding the license imposed restrictive and wanting a separate thing as to not have to worry about said license, though i am unsure.

last i checked, beechat was having issues with their products actually working, has that changed?

---

## Reply 10

**oatmilk!** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 12:38 AM

**iamGBOX** wrote:
 
> RNS has been gaining fantastic ground in the last few years, but there's still so much further to go where adoption and exploring real-world use is concerned. It's not yet a system-critical component for public or private operations, as far as I'm aware, and if it is, the groups using it damn well better be putting their resources behind it's development.

my local volunteer and such org has been looking into this, and currently i am working on getting an actual infrastructure test set up, once i stop having life shit happen, i will absolutely be trying to convince them to toss some money at mark

---

## Reply 11

**Zenith** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 12:44 AM

and something I haven't seen brought up is this: What could a universal RNS governance body do in terms of network coordination? 

This is something that has to be delegated to the local or regional level.  There is no one size fits all network deployment. As an example, I'm from Knoxville, TN here in the US.  This is an area that has a huge saturation of both MeshCore and Meshtastic devices. With regards to Meshtastic much of this was self-organizing. 

If the goal was to create network infrastructure with LoRa or similar hardware, the challenges are primarily geography. to create a network that can serve a local area is something that must be planned by individual volunteers in relation to location and the resources they have available.

for the guys doing MeshCore stuff here most of them are involved in ARES or regional ham clubs. You can see the network map here: https://map.meshcore.io/?lat=35.9582&lon=-83.9596&zoom=12.06 

coordination on a local level like this is not possible by a third-party. i'm not sure what resources could hypothetically be provided other than what is already available. 

the geography, population density, local laws, frequencies, and infrastructure are going to vary just about everywhere on earth. likewise the design constraints and goals will too.

---

## Reply 12

**Quackman1** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 1:13 AM

**Zenith** wrote:
> and something I haven't seen brought up is this: What could a universal RNS governance body do in terms of network coordination? 
> 
> This is something that has to be delegated to the local or regional level.  There is no one size fits all network deployment. As an example, I'm from Knoxville, TN here in the US.  This is an area that has a huge saturation of both MeshCore and Meshtastic devices. With regards to Meshtastic much of this was self-organizing. 
> 
> If the goal was to create network infrastructure with LoRa or similar hardware, the challenges are primarily geography. to create a network that can serve a local area is something that must be planned by individual volunteers in relation to location and the resources they have available.
> 
> for the guys doing MeshCore stuff here most of them are involved in ARES or regional ham clubs. You can see the network map here: https://map.meshcore.io/?lat=35.9582&lon=-83.9596&zoom=12.06 
> 
> coordination on a local level like this is not possible by a third-party. i'm not sure what resources could hypothetically be provided other than what is already available. 
> 
> the geography, population density, local laws, frequencies, and infrastructure are going to vary just about everywhere on earth. likewise the design constraints and goals will too.

Hi Zenith,

I have a few thoughts on this, im not sure about a third-party or governing body but here are my thoughts in terms of individualistic volunteer expansion for reticulum - 

1) Reduce the education barrier, as of now Reticulum has a very high ceiling of learning-curve, when people make LLM-variants of Reticulum its because they don't even know whats the problem with what they're doing (even if they're violating the license they might not know about bad network behaviour or whatever)
2) forums/posts and any marketing related to reticulum is very obscure and only with ai scraping the entire web did it suggest me this forum and a bit more rest are even dead if i say so
3) sell software/hardware more readily available and ui-friendly. As of now, its quite easy to get really good-looking apps and easily sourced hardware for meshtastic/meshcore.
4) educate how reticulum is better
5) integrate usecases like ATAK or crypto or bluetooth (maybe even games like chess over LoRa or even emulator games over wifi/tcp) and people will automatically use it more 
6) the homepages on reticulum are really good just build awareness on it, nomadnet for example is hard to use according to ui but if sideband mobile or columba (havent used columba dunno if it has it) had a browser that wud be great.

---

## Reply 13

**oatmilk!** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 2:43 AM

did the forum eat my reply that i typed out or did it get deleted :/

---

## Reply 14

**oatmilk!** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 2:55 AM

trying this again, may be a bit more curt

**Quackman1** wrote:

> 1) Reduce the education barrier, as of now Reticulum has a very high ceiling of learning-curve, when people make LLM-variants of Reticulum its because they don't even know whats the problem with what they're doing (even if they're violating the license they might not know about bad network behaviour or whatever)

https://reticulum.network/manual/index.html, reading is important, it's 10 pages for the quickstart guide, honestly you could just do the quick start guide as RNS-Quickstart.pdf and it would be less scary to people, idk, you can also just look at existing programs, they're open source

> 2) forums/posts and any marketing related to reticulum is very obscure and only with ai scraping the entire web did it suggest me this forum and a bit more rest are even dead if i say so

issue with lack of marketing is that AFIK this is not intended to be a business venture, if we want to make a advertising group in here or something like that you could prolly do that. use websearch rather than AI, most ai services are not scraping reticulum.network due to legal threats (made or implied) around doing that with the software

> 3) sell software/hardware more readily available and ui-friendly. As of now, its quite easy to get really good-looking apps and easily sourced hardware for meshtastic/meshcore.

hardware is already sold just not by name, most meshtastic devices can be flashed to run rnode, check out meshchatx

> 4) educate how reticulum is better

anyone who doesn't care is not going to care that what you have is *better* unless it offers a usecase that the other ones do not (like webpages) that is not served better by something that they already have (a web browser)

> 5) integrate usecases like ATAK or crypto or bluetooth (maybe even games like chess over LoRa or even emulator games over wifi/tcp) and people will automatically use it more 

- atak may be too close to harm, if you want to work on an atak setup for it, we can make our own thread for that
-why crypto
-unsure how useful games/rns would be, that said, rns is basicly 90s internet, we got MUDs and iirc i saw a chess implementation somewhere, idk how much sense it would make for it to be built into the app, but you can always pull-> fork -> push to main -> and maybe it'll be merged into NN or smthn 
-see point 4
> 6) the homepages on reticulum are really good just build awareness on it,

- see point 2 i think?

> nomadnet for example is hard to use according to ui but if sideband mobile or columba (havent used columba dunno if it has it) had a browser that wud be great.

- NN is fine IMO, if anything it's more modern that a lot of people like their term programs
- try meshchatx


to be clear, this is not meant as "this is stupid" and more a "hey this already exists, you may not know of it :D"

---

## Reply 15

**Zenith** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 3:12 AM

**Quackman1** wrote:
> **Zenith** wrote:
> > and something I haven't seen brought up is this: What could a universal RNS governance body do in terms of network coordination? 
> > 
> > This is something that has to be delegated to the local or regional level.  There is no one size fits all network deployment. As an example, I'm from Knoxville, TN here in the US.  This is an area that has a huge saturation of both MeshCore and Meshtastic devices. With regards to Meshtastic much of this was self-organizing. 
> > 
> > If the goal was to create network infrastructure with LoRa or similar hardware, the challenges are primarily geography. to create a network that can serve a local area is something that must be planned by individual volunteers in relation to location and the resources they have available.
> > 
> > for the guys doing MeshCore stuff here most of them are involved in ARES or regional ham clubs. You can see the network map here: https://map.meshcore.io/?lat=35.9582&lon=-83.9596&zoom=12.06 
> > 
> > coordination on a local level like this is not possible by a third-party. i'm not sure what resources could hypothetically be provided other than what is already available. 
> > 
> > the geography, population density, local laws, frequencies, and infrastructure are going to vary just about everywhere on earth. likewise the design constraints and goals will too.
> 
> Hi Zenith,
> 
> I have a few thoughts on this, im not sure about a third-party or governing body but here are my thoughts in terms of individualistic volunteer expansion for reticulum - 
> 
> 1) Reduce the education barrier, as of now Reticulum has a very high ceiling of learning-curve, when people make LLM-variants of Reticulum its because they don't even know whats the problem with what they're doing (even if they're violating the license they might not know about bad network behaviour or whatever)
> 2) forums/posts and any marketing related to reticulum is very obscure and only with ai scraping the entire web did it suggest me this forum and a bit more rest are even dead if i say so
> 3) sell software/hardware more readily available and ui-friendly. As of now, its quite easy to get really good-looking apps and easily sourced hardware for meshtastic/meshcore.
> 4) educate how reticulum is better
> 5) integrate usecases like ATAK or crypto or bluetooth (maybe even games like chess over LoRa or even emulator games over wifi/tcp) and people will automatically use it more 
> 6) the homepages on reticulum are really good just build awareness on it, nomadnet for example is hard to use according to ui but if sideband mobile or columba (havent used columba dunno if it has it) had a browser that wud be great.

Agree with just about everything here. The manual is good, but yeah, some more resources would be nice :)

That would be a good initiative for anyone who wants to put stuff like that together, and one of the goals of this forum.

---

## Reply 16

**Quackman1** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 9:48 AM

**oatmilk!** wrote:
> trying this again, may be a bit more curt
> 
> **Quackman1** wrote:
> 
> > 1) Reduce the education barrier, as of now Reticulum has a very high ceiling of learning-curve, when people make LLM-variants of Reticulum its because they don't even know whats the problem with what they're doing (even if they're violating the license they might not know about bad network behaviour or whatever)
> 
> https://reticulum.network/manual/index.html, reading is important, it's 10 pages for the quickstart guide, honestly you could just do the quick start guide as RNS-Quickstart.pdf and it would be less scary to people, idk, you can also just look at existing programs, they're open source
> 
> > 2) forums/posts and any marketing related to reticulum is very obscure and only with ai scraping the entire web did it suggest me this forum and a bit more rest are even dead if i say so
> 
> issue with lack of marketing is that AFIK this is not intended to be a business venture, if we want to make a advertising group in here or something like that you could prolly do that. use websearch rather than AI, most ai services are not scraping reticulum.network due to legal threats (made or implied) around doing that with the software
> 
> > 3) sell software/hardware more readily available and ui-friendly. As of now, its quite easy to get really good-looking apps and easily sourced hardware for meshtastic/meshcore.
> 
> hardware is already sold just not by name, most meshtastic devices can be flashed to run rnode, check out meshchatx
> 
> > 4) educate how reticulum is better
> 
> anyone who doesn't care is not going to care that what you have is *better* unless it offers a usecase that the other ones do not (like webpages) that is not served better by something that they already have (a web browser)
> 
> > 5) integrate usecases like ATAK or crypto or bluetooth (maybe even games like chess over LoRa or even emulator games over wifi/tcp) and people will automatically use it more 
> 
> - atak may be too close to harm, if you want to work on an atak setup for it, we can make our own thread for that
> -why crypto
> -unsure how useful games/rns would be, that said, rns is basicly 90s internet, we got MUDs and iirc i saw a chess implementation somewhere, idk how much sense it would make for it to be built into the app, but you can always pull-> fork -> push to main -> and maybe it'll be merged into NN or smthn 
> -see point 4
> > 6) the homepages on reticulum are really good just build awareness on it,
> 
> - see point 2 i think?
> 
> > nomadnet for example is hard to use according to ui but if sideband mobile or columba (havent used columba dunno if it has it) had a browser that wud be great.
> 
> - NN is fine IMO, if anything it's more modern that a lot of people like their term programs
> - try meshchatx
> 
> 
> to be clear, this is not meant as "this is stupid" and more a "hey this already exists, you may not know of it :D" 
> 

Hi Oatmilk,

Thanks Meshchatx is really good and literally solves a lot of the problems but i never really knew about it. Similarly as for the rest of the points i appreciate them just wanted to put my opinion as a newcomer out there.

---

## Reply 17

**flok** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 10:02 AM

Thank you LadyInGreen for taking the time to parse and re-write what has been said. I'm gonna take my time to read this over the weekend. I quickly read trough this thread and I see you're underlining some important issues around the critical infra lab that I will have a think about. Delivering this in a good faith manner helps me a lot to engage seriously with the content of the critiques instead of having to focus on responding to hostility. I'll also respond to Mark's message from the previous thread in the next days.

---

## Reply 18

**Rudi Mentaire** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 10:11 AM

@LadyInGreen thank you for this very well written summery.

The community here is fine, the developer(s) doing a fantasic job. That's what really counts. They are only put under constant stress.

I dunno the intentions of the "CriticalInfraLab" people and the others Don't intend to say the intentions are bad. But the fact that nearly everything coming from "the outside" being distraction and psychological pressure, intended or not, but OTOH no real, helpful support or money, is a fact that tells a lot. That these people cause actual, real harm to the project, tells a lot. They are either not understanding the project and its goals, or they are not understanding what they are doing. Either is bad. Or they intentionally want to be harmful.

Anyway: Reticulum is free software. Anybody can create a reticulum 2, or, talk about it, modify it, do good things, bad things, organize an event, a thousand events. All is good if Mark can continue his work. There always will be thousands of people who know better but don't actually do anything good or meaningful at all. One can't avoid that. Just do your thing, prepare that it may get even worse. The community will learn how to ignore and dispel annoying people even more efficiently if it has to.

Everybody is allowed to discuss Reticulum, everybody is allowed to help, and Mark decides what Mark wants to do, like every other human being.

---

## Reply 19

**Mark** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 11:28 AM

Context regarding @lava's second post:
https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reply-to-reticulum-developer-summit-20262027#post-4263

Without knowing *who actually formulated and decided* on those "developer summit topics", this whole discussion can probably only ever devolve into strangeness. I think *that* is really the most pertinent question, *if* one wants to dive further into all of this.

I do not intend to dive further into this, for now. I intend to take the small break I've been trying to get for two weeks now ;) I'll go see if I can find a rock to stare at.

---

## Reply 20

**LadyInGreen** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 11:29 AM

We now have a [response from @lava in a separate thread](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/reply-to-reticulum-developer-summit-20262027), giving a bit more context for this "developer summit".

I try to quote main points from @lava here and post further questions for this organization:

> I apologize for not giving more context on where this invitation comes from and what our intentions are.

Thanks, more context would have been great! However reading your full reply I still do not have an answer to what your intentions are with the initial topics you proposed for your summit?

I assume someone from your group thought a bit about this and listed the topics most relevant to your group as the initial starting point and I am curious as to why 67% of your topics concern coordination/governance of the reticulum project as a whole and the countless communities surrounding Reticulum? 

> The group I refer to, the "we" in the original invitation, is a loosely organized group of community organizers, hackers, artists and activists who have been organizing many reticulum workshops at autonomous centers, squats and cultural spaces in the Netherlands and beyond.

OK, now I better understand the conflation between voluntary community workshops and the summit invitation!
Looking at [the link you provided](https://radar.squat.net/en/reticulum-low-countries/archive), the general community work you seem to have been organizing looks awesome. No hard feelings from anyone on that point I think!

Your initial invite very much made it sound like this came from CriticalInfraLab and you had many references to them in your initial invite including signing yourself as "Lava, with the critical infrastructure lab" and "the research is done in collaboration with Maxigas (Dr. Peter Dunajcsik)".

> The list of topics to discuss at the summit is only a proposal and there are, naturally, contested ones.

IMHO this reply "there are, naturally, contested ones" in the response to the topics criticized, is a **very** vague and non-satisfying answer to all the concerned raised!

> To respond to Mark's concern, I have not heard anything about replacing RNS...

Your initial topics proposed for this "developer summit" very much suggested this. I hear no acknowledgment from your side about the concern raised on the agenda points, only a vague "I have not heard anything".

> What is also true is that here are no networks without communities maintaining them.

I think **everyone** here acknowledges this, and I have never seen any hostility towards communities building networks, sharing knowledge and discussing Reticulum in general.

That being said, communities exists who calls for the *removal of Mark from core Reticulum development* and the replacement of him "by a community driven implementation", the replacement proposed is often maintained by a different single person, no real community implementation have ever showed itself and could never have solved the problems Mark is solving in RNS. Most of these one-man "communities" can expect a well deserved push-back when posting in this forum!

An example being a person called Liam with [this presentation](https://archive.fosdem.org/2026/events/attachments/9NCWUR-reticulum_community_meetup_implementations_migration_and_future/slides/267005/reticulum_dimz1j8.pdf)  as a FOSDEM event. They acknowledge that Mark is still maintaining the RNS protocol behind the scenes (as he explicitly stated time and time again, that absurd discussion, like this one, are draining all his energy from core development).

Liam's group embraces the use of Beechat's implementation instead of RNS and have a full slide stating: **A healthy project must separate from its founder.**

Or [Jobi Jara Kroese](https://archive.fosdem.org/2026/schedule/speaker/jobi_jara_kroese/) with "shared protocol spec scope and an initial conformance/test-vector plan that enables independent implementations", a protocol spec that will undoubtedly diverge from RNS itself. Especially since it is LLM-generated and get important parts of the protocol wrong. See [Mark's notes on these "specs" here](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/brandolinis-reference-or-alternatively-agentsmd?page=1#post-3005).

As we have seen clearly already, people are perfectly capable of creating Reticulum implementations *that actually work and interoperate with the reference* without any external LLM-generated "protocol specs" made by people who did not themselves seems to have read a single line of the reference implementation.

Now I will ask you this to rule out the possibility (as your agenda points to decentralizing of RNS and a separate Reticulum Foundation and protocol spec): 
Are you Liam? Or Jobi? Who are you actually?

Your "summit" agenda with *decentralization of development* and *a reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers* very much points towards "decentralization" of Reticulum core development, *by* the removal of Mark.

So far your groups response to this real criticism have been non-existent.

> it was hurtful to read through the comments and I hope rns.recipes can be a more welcoming space in the future.

You replied you felt hurt by the response you received here on rns.recipies. 

You initiated a "developer summit" with these agenda suggestions:
- *decentralization of development* - This could only point to RNS itself, as everything else is already 100% decentralized.
- *a reticulum foundation to manage and distribute funds for developers* - **Without** ever contacting the active inventor/creator/maintainer of the network-stack to discuss this.

You literately **catapulted a big blob of mud at the core developers** - without taking responsibility for this or acknowledging this. And your response to the criticism is that you felt hurt and stating the space is unwelcoming when the mud was catapulted back.

Why is it hurtful to you that people reject external governance/coordinators of Reticulum and its communities as a whole? Aren't you the one talking about "decetralization"?

Why did you think people would embrace the proposed topics with open arms?

Do you think this is perfectly valid topics to discuss at a "developer summit" where core developers and maintainers are not present?

Do you not see the rudeness in this? 

Why do you think it is your task to discuss a Reticulum Foundation without coordination with Mark?

___

Further I would still like to see replies to the list of [questions posted earlier](https://rns.recipes/forum/general/on-the-criticalinfralabs-invitation-to-a-reticulum-developer-summit#post-4235) from the organizers of this "developer summit", and I would love to hear the thoughts behind the initially listed topics by anyone involved with the arrangement of this "developer summit".

---

## Reply 21

**Nickie** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 2:48 PM

**Mark** wrote:
> I do not intend to dive further into this, for now. I intend to take the small break I've been trying to get for two weeks now ;) I'll go see if I can find a rock to stare at.

It's great news, at least we will have some time to prepare for 1.6.2 and internalize it. Take some well-deserved rest!

---

## Reply 22

**jan Epiphany** · Sat, Nov 21, 2026 11:11 PM

The hour has struck
and your time, come,
delging a tsunami of shit
is now your new fun ;).
No more of this
silly "accountability,"
c'est la vie.
Your project, devoured,
will become ours,
bend the knee.

---
